Jesse James at Bay

Roy Rogers

Jesse James / Clint Burns

George 'Gabby' Hayes

Sheriff Gabby Whitaker

Sally Payne

Polly Morgan

Pierre Watkin

Phineas Krager - Land Dealer

Ivan Miller

Judge Rutherford

Hal Taliaferro

Paul Sloan, Lawyer

Gale Storm

Jane Fillmore, 'St. Louis Journal' Reporter

Roy Barcroft

Henchman Vern Stone

Jack Kirk

Henchman Rufe Balder

Chester Conklin

Town Drunk (uncredited)

John Dilson

Collins (uncredited)

Jack Rockwell

Townsman (uncredited)

Rick Anderson

Card Player

Chuck Baldra

Townsman

Hank Bell

Charlie Davis

William Benedict

Young Davis